The Aperlena Verdict
Open raceNo supplier dominates: 6 different companies have won the last 6 comparable contracts from this buyer over 5 years. This is a genuinely open race.
Based on 6 comparable awards by this buyer in this sector over 5 years. Every verdict is recorded before the outcome and graded against the award notice. How we score ourselves.
Summary
Machine-generated summaryThe contracting authority is procuring structural engineering design services for the new construction of a preventive detention facility at Tonna Prison in Germany. The service covers specialist structural planning under § 51 HOAI for service phases 2 to 6 plus a special service in phase 8 (performance levels 1 to 4). The procedure is a negotiated procedure with participant competition in two stages: first, applicants submit an application form with the required information and evidence by the set deadline; the most suitable applicants are then invited to the second stage, where they submit initial offers that are negotiated. After final non-negotiable offers, bidders present themselves personally before a jury. Details of the planning scope are published in the document '0881-26 Beschreibung der Baumaßnahme.pdf'.
Description
Terms of the procedure
- How tenders are scored
- 1.1.1 Vorstellung: Projektorganisation und Projektstruktur: 20 percent; 1.2.1 Vorstellung: Projektteam: 10 percent; 1.2.2 Vorstellung: Projektteam: 5 percent; 1.3.1 Vorstellung: Herangehensweise bezogen auf den Auftragsgegenstand: 15 percent; 1.3.2 Vorstellung: Herangehensweise bezogen auf den Auftragsgegenstand: 10 percent; 1.3.3 Vorstellung: Herangehensweise bezogen auf den Auftragsgegenstand: 5 percent; 1.4.1 Vorstellung: Beantwortung von Fragen aus der Jury: 5 percent; 1.4.2 Vorstellung: Beantwortung von Fragen aus der Jury: 5 percent; 2.1 Preis: Honorarangebot: 20 percent
- Small firms
- The buyer marks this procedure as suitable for small and medium-sized firms.
- Tenders go to
- evergabe-online.de/tenderdetails.html?id=895221
As the official notice states them.
Bid or no-bid?
Six questions before you commit a team. Under each one, what the register holds on it. The answers are yours.
Can I bid?
- Negotiated procedure: the buyer negotiates the terms with the suppliers it admits. Above the EU threshold: open to companies from any EU country.
- The notice is written in German.
- Certificates from another EU country? Check the equivalents on eCertis
Official source
Source: TED - Tenders Electronic Daily (Publications Office of the EU)
Always verify details on the official notice.
Report an error in this notice
Last verified against TED - Tenders Electronic Daily (Publications Office of the EU) 2 days ago
Expected award price
- likely award for this notice, from its published estimate of €553,000
- €425,810 to €569,590
Comparable awards in this country and sector came in at a median of 97% of their published estimate, half of them between 77% and 103%, based on 716 awards of the last 3 years.
Each award is compared with the estimate of the same lots, framework agreements excluded. A published estimate may include options and renewals, so an award under it is not always a discount.
What this buyer has paid before
Based on 6 comparable contracts this buyer awarded in this sector over the last 4 years.
- This notice
- €553,000
- Median award
- €337,870
- Middle half of past awards
- €111,225 to €757,472
The estimate sits inside the usual range.
Most recent awards
- Dienstleistungen in der Tragwerksplanung - Zentralisierung der Aus- und Fortbildung der Thüringer Landesverwaltung am Standort Gotha - Bildungszentrum Gotha - 2. Bauabschnitt Neubau eines Lehrsaalgebäudes auf dem jetzigen Standort der Sporthalle Tragwerksplanung €82,766
- Architectural services for buildings - Tonna Prison, new preventive detention building €2,126,295
- Dienstleistungen von Architekturbüros bei Gebäuden - Zentralisierung der Aus- und Fortbildung der Thüringer Landesverwaltung am Standort Gotha - Bildungszentrum Gotha - 2. Bauabschnitt Neubau eines Lehrsaalgebäudes auf dem jetzigen Standort der Sporthalle €479,140
- Dienstleistungen im Elektrobereich - Bundesbehördenzentrum „Am Steigerwald“, Neuerrichtung ESB-Standort €196,600
- Gutachterische Tätigkeit - Thüringen Kliniken „Georgius Agricola“ GmbH, Erweiterungsbau der Thüringen-Kliniken am Standort Saalfeld €850,250
Award values as published by the official sources. Use them as a guide, not a rule: scope, lots and duration differ between contracts.
The buyer
Full buyer profileThüringer Landesamt für Bau und Verkehr (TLBV)
- notices in the register
- 27
- awards
- 8
- awarded in total
- €3.8M
One dot per award, on the day it was signed, sized by its value. A ring is an award with no published value.
Who usually wins this buyer's contracts in this sector
| Company | Wins | Total awarded | Last win |
|---|---|---|---|
| agn Niederberghaus & Partner GmbH in Halle | 1 | €2.1M | Aug 2026 |
| tp management GmbH | 1 | €850,250 | Apr 2026 |
| hks Architekten | 1 | €479,140 | Aug 2026 |
| IB elektroplan-schneider GmbH | 1 | €196,600 | Apr 2026 |
| RuP Ruffert Ingenieurgesellschaft mbH | 1 | €82,766 | Sep 2026 |
Based on 6 awards with a linked company profile over the last 5 years.
4 open tenders right now
- Architectural services for buildings - LPI Suhl, new heating supply building 2025 IEE 0005, building design services 1 day to request
- Heating planning - Centralisation of training for the Thuringia state administration in Gotha - Education Centre Gotha - 2nd construction phase, new lecture building - Specialist planning for plumbing, heating and ventilation systems No deadline published
- Architectural services for open spaces - Centralisation of training for the Thuringia state administration in Gotha - Education Centre Gotha - Phase 2: new lecture hall building on the current sports hall site - Open space design services No deadline published
Market context
Larger than 63% of the open notices in Architecture & engineering services across Europe.
- open now in Architecture & engineering services
- 7,698
- median open notice
- €300,000
Who wins in this market
Many suppliersGermany · Architecture & engineering services
- different companies won awards here
- 6,853
- of the awards went to the three most frequent winners
- 3%
- buyers awarded contracts here
- 3,460
Based on 12,428 awards with a named winner over the last 3 years. Counted by award, not by value, because lot and framework amounts are not comparable. Concentrated means the three most frequent winners took 65% or more of the awards; many suppliers, under 35% with at least ten different winners.
Competition
- tenders per lot on average (open and restricted procedures)
- 5.5
- of those lots received a single tender
- 11%
- of the awards went to companies based in another country
- 1%
- of the tenders came from another country
- 5%
As the official award notices state them, over the last 3 years. Tenders per lot count open and restricted procedures only: in a negotiated procedure or a direct award a single tender is the procedure itself. The country is the one the notice gives for the winner.
Similar tenders
Open now
4
days to request
€373,019
est. value
1
day to request
€91,563
est. value
Awarded before
Never miss a tender like this
543 new notices in Architecture & engineering services in Germany in the last 7 days. Get an email when new ones appear. Free.
Set up my alertOr follow just its CPV code, Load-bearing structure design services: an email when new tenders arrive under it, no account needed.