The Aperlena Verdict
Open raceNo supplier dominates: 12 different companies have won the last 13 comparable contracts from this buyer over 5 years. This is a genuinely open race.
Based on 13 comparable awards by this buyer in this sector over 5 years. Every verdict is recorded before the outcome and graded against the award notice. How we score ourselves.
Summary
Machine-generated summaryThe City of Genoa is procuring, through an open procedure awarded to the most economically advantageous tender, the separate collection of paper and cardboard in two lots. Lot 1 covers roadside separate collection of paper and cardboard (CER 20.01.01). Lot 2 covers separate collection of paper and cardboard packaging (CER 15.01.01). The services are to be carried out across the territory of the Municipality of Genoa, covering the kerbside collection of paper and cardboard waste and of paper and cardboard packaging under the two contracted lots.
Description
2 lots
- Lot 1
- Lotto 1 Raccolta carta stradale CER 20.01.01 estimated €8,452,320
- Lot 2
- Lotto 2 Imballi in cartone CER 15.01.01 estimated €8,404,600
- How tenders are scored
- Quality; Price The lots are scored differently: the official notice gives each lot its own criteria.
As the official notice states them.
Bid or no-bid?
Six questions before you commit a team. Under each one, what the register holds on it. The answers are yours.
Can I bid?
- Open procedure: any interested supplier may submit a bid. Above the EU threshold: open to companies from any EU country.
- The notice is written in Italian.
- Certificates from another EU country? Check the equivalents on eCertis
Official source
Source: TED - Tenders Electronic Daily (Publications Office of the EU)
Always verify details on the official notice.
Report an error in this notice
Last verified against TED - Tenders Electronic Daily (Publications Office of the EU) 2 days ago
Expected award price
- likely award for this notice, from its published estimate of €16,856,920
- €7.6M to €15.7M
Comparable awards in this country and sector came in at a median of 70% of their published estimate, half of them between 45% and 93%, based on 1,297 awards of the last 3 years.
Each award is compared with the estimate of the same lots, framework agreements excluded. A published estimate may include options and renewals, so an award under it is not always a discount.
What this buyer has paid before
Based on 13 comparable contracts this buyer awarded in this sector over the last 4 years.
- This notice
- €16.9M
- Median award
- €1.4M
- Middle half of past awards
- €439,252 to €1.7M
The estimate is larger than three in four past awards.
Most recent awards
- Collection and treatment services for non-hazardous municipal and household waste (48/2026), open procedure, framework agreement with a single operator €2,059,355
- Urban and non-hazardous household waste treatment and disposal services - (48/2026) - Lot 2 Volpara €1,445,240
- Street cleaning and sweeping services - (05/2026) Open procedure for manual street cleaning in the municipalities of Arenzano, Cogoleto, Campo Ligure, Tiglieto, Mele, Masone and Rossiglione €877,626
- Servizi di pulizia - (100/2025) Procedura aperta, con aggiudicazione secondo il criterio dell'offerta economicamente più vantaggiosa, per la scelta del contraente cui affidare servizio di pulizia dei locali aziendali, comprensivo della fornitura di prodotti per l'igiene a basso impatto ambientale (CAM D.M. 51 del 29 gennaio 2021, in G.U. n. 42 del 19 febbraio 2021), della durata di 3 (tre) anni €1,646,330
- Trattamento e smaltimento dei rifiuti - (112/25) Procedura aperta, ai sensi dellart. 71 del D.Lgs. n. 36/2023, con aggiudicazione secondo il criterio del minor prezzo, ai sensi dellart. 108, comma 3 del D.Lgs. n. 36/2023, per la scelta del contraente cui affidare le attività di esecuzione del servizio di ritiro vuoto per pieno, trasporto e avvio a recupero delle frazioni della raccolta differenziata CER 20.01.38 legno diverso da quello €237,360
Award values as published by the official sources. Use them as a guide, not a rule: scope, lots and duration differ between contracts.
The buyer
Full buyer profileGare Amiu Genova
- notices in the register
- 112
- awards
- 49
- awarded in total
- €61.1M
Who wins its contracts
Many suppliers- different companies won its awards
- 30
- of the awards went to the three most frequent winners
- 18%
- of its calls state an estimated value
- 100%
Based on 33 awards with a named winner over the last 3 years. Counted by award, not by value, because lot and framework amounts are not comparable. Concentrated means the three most frequent winners took 65% or more of the awards; many suppliers, under 35% with at least ten different winners.
Competition
- tenders per lot on average (open and restricted procedures)
- 2.1
- of those lots received a single tender
- 38%
- of the awards went to companies based in another country
- 0%
As the official award notices state them, over the last 3 years. Tenders per lot count open and restricted procedures only: in a negotiated procedure or a direct award a single tender is the procedure itself. The country is the one the notice gives for the winner.
One dot per award, on the day it was signed, sized by its value. A ring is an award with no published value.
Who usually wins this buyer's contracts in this sector
| Company | Wins | Total awarded | Last win |
|---|---|---|---|
| CONSORZIO SOCIALE OMNIA | 2 | €1.1M | Jul 2026 |
| A2A Ambiente S.p.A.; Rea Dalmine; ACINQUE AMBIENTE SRL | 1 | €29.4M | Nov 2025 |
| ARCHIMEDE SOCIETA' COOPERATIVA SOCIALE; Andrea Badaracco | 1 | €2.4M | Jun 2025 |
| IREN AMBIENTE S.P.A. | 1 | €2.1M | Jul 2026 |
| Idealservice Soc. Coop. | 1 | €1.7M | Jan 2025 |
Based on 13 awards with a linked company profile over the last 5 years.
4 open tenders right now
- Landfill management services - Cleaning of leachate extraction wells at the Monte Scarpino landfill, Genoa 7 days left
- Collection, transport and recovery of mixed construction and demolition waste (EER 17.09.04), including container and big bag supply 7 days left
- Waste containers - Supply of 335 computerised containers for undifferentiated waste collection 28 days left
Market context
Larger than 95% of the open notices in Environment, sewage & cleaning across Europe.
- open now in Environment, sewage & cleaning
- 4,615
- median open notice
- €499,182
Who wins in this market
Many suppliersItaly · Environment, sewage & cleaning
- different companies won awards here
- 1,234
- of the awards went to the three most frequent winners
- 3%
- buyers awarded contracts here
- 841
Based on 1,803 awards with a named winner over the last 3 years. Counted by award, not by value, because lot and framework amounts are not comparable. Concentrated means the three most frequent winners took 65% or more of the awards; many suppliers, under 35% with at least ten different winners.
Competition
- tenders per lot on average (open and restricted procedures)
- 3.5
- of those lots received a single tender
- 35%
- of the awards went to companies based in another country
- 1%
- of the tenders came from another country
- 0%
As the official award notices state them, over the last 3 years. Tenders per lot count open and restricted procedures only: in a negotiated procedure or a direct award a single tender is the procedure itself. The country is the one the notice gives for the winner.
Similar tenders
Open now
23
days left
€15,559,601
est. value
30
days left
€7,597,549
est. value
31
days left
€9,952,235
est. value
37
days left
€15,358,552
est. value
Open elsewhere in Europe
10
days left
€896,000
est. value
Matched by meaning across languages, from the notices' own words: the same kind of contract, open now in another country.
Awarded before
Never miss a tender like this
127 new notices in Environment, sewage & cleaning in Italy in the last 7 days. Get an email when new ones appear. Free.
Set up my alertOr follow just its CPV code, Paper collecting services: an email when new tenders arrive under it, no account needed.